top of page

A

SUBTERRANEAN

TIER

How an identity crisis amongst poverty stricken youth in London is fueling gang subculture.

Photo by Unsplash

This year, London has witnessed a spike in serious youth violence likely driven by gang conflict and drug dealing. NHS hospitals have seen a 17 percent rise in stabbings and, of 69 murders in the capital, 24 victims were under the age of 21.

 

It is near-impossible to determine how many kids are actively involved in gang culture. However according to a Home Office report, Londoners were the most likely group to report increasing gang activity in their local area. Many have blamed a reduction in police numbers, poverty and deprivation, as well as violent music. Yet London’s issue with gangs is a multilayered, self fuelling problem that we are only just beginning to understand.

 

 

83%

 

of children are worried

about youth violence

 

Source: Ben Kinsella Trust 

 

 

14%

 

of children know someone who has carried a knife

 

Source: Ben Kinsella Trust 

The Identity

Crisis.

Nana Agyeman

Managing Director of AccessUK, a charity for young black males

The Home Office defines a street gang as a durable, predominantly street-based group of young people who see themselves (and are seen by others) as a discernible group, and engage in a range of criminal activity and violence”. But the term ‘gang’ is contentious. Youths will use this terminology because that's what they have been told they are. But there is little order or structure to a lot of these ‘gangs’. They are not ‘a discernible group’, being highly transient, having few rules or regulations. However a minority do fulfill their description, and it is from these small groups that the violence and criminality stem.

 

The Windrush scandal has caused the issue of cultural identity to resurface, and for many of London’s minority youth, they don’t know who they are or where they fit in. This generation face an identity crisis, they do not feel part of British society, and nor do they feel like they belong at home where their grandparents or great-grandparents came from.

 

AccessUK is a charity for BME youth in London, and their director, Nana Agyeman, has seen the effect this crisis is having. “If you don't feel like a part of the society in terms of finding a job and just getting on in life - you are stuck in a limbo. That lack of self worth and value translates into the streets, because If you have no value for yourself, what is going to stop you from hurting another human being?” Because of this feeling of worthlessness, these youth feel that they have no stake in the community and they feel that they have nothing to lose by engaging in gang culture.

 

Gangs offer feeling of belonging, something which their members are maybe lacking. “Gangs provide many adolescents and young adults with a sense of belonging and purpose, and can add structure to their lives,” says Dr Vas Sivarajasingam, Director at the National Violence Surveillance Network. “The gangs have also been viewed as possible replacement for family.”

​

“It is clear they don't have the self respect to actually believe they can do anything else.” says Patrick Green of the Ben Kinsella Trust. “A crippling sense of low self esteem is driving kids towards gang-life.” This absence of self belief goes hand-in-hand with a lack of opportunities for many young people, with London having the second highest youth unemployment rate in the United Kingdom. Over 70,000 people aged 16-24 were out of work or education in the capital at the end of March 2018.

 

The lack of opportunities and self esteem is further amplified by a lack of recognisable role models, especially for young black males, Mr Agyeman says. “The role models are there but they are not visible, they will do talks but in prestigious places, like university or parliament. But that isn't reaching the people it really needs to.” This plays directly into the hands of gang members looking to recruit young new members, with children able to make up to a thousand pounds a week running and selling drugs.

55%

of black and minority youth aged 18-24 are unemployed

 

Source: ONS 

Above: What comes to mind when you think of the word 'Gang'? 

In an effort to stand out from the crowd and succeed, gang members are resorting to more and more extreme methods to raise their social standing in the gang.

 

Photo by Unsplash

 Changing nature of

the gang.

Widespread availability of cheap, disposable mobile phones and the internet has ushered in an era where drugs are no more than a text away, delivered direct to your door. The Global Drug Survey reported that drugs could be delivered faster than a pizza in London, thanks to changes in the drug market.

 

Gang members will often coerce or entice children on bikes, and older youths on mopeds into doing their deliveries for easy money, and pull them into the orbit of the gang.

 

Of course, where there are drugs, there will be weapons. The risk of being attacked and robbed by rival gang members, or even members of their own gang, means these runners will always be carrying a weapon for self defense. “Most of these weapon-related homicides in London have been linked to drugs and gang violence” says Dr Sivarajasingam.

 

A volatile mix of frustrated youth, drug money, and weapons has transformed the street gang into an arena of intense and violent social competition. Fuelled by a small minority of London's youth seeking to build a notoriety or what Dr Simon Harding, a criminologist with the University of West London calls ‘street capital’.

​

Research also shows fewer people are maturing out of the gang as they get older, meaning a lot more competition. In an effort to stand out from the crowd and succeed, younger gang members are resorting to more and more extreme methods to raise their social standing in the gang. Mr Duncan Bew, head trauma surgeon at King's College Hospital, has witnessed this ferocity. ”Instead of single stab wounds we are seeing more cases of multiple stab wounds, inferred from that, a change in the intent. Instead of just trying to harm or maim someone, we are seeing more people that are trying to kill.”

Dr Vas Sivarajasingam

Director, National Violence Surveillance Network

Image: Cardiff University

Above: 69 people have been killed in London this year, with much of the violence linked to gang and knife crime.

24 of the victims were aged 21 or younger. Data for this map was compiled by hand from the London Metropolitan Police news and other sources. 

“Young kids don’t want to walk through rival kids territory to get there as that puts them at risk so they simply won’t go”

 

Photo by Echo Grid on Unsplash

Nowhere to go.

London Mayor

Sadiq Khan

Condemns youth spending cuts

in press release 

Youth centres and projects have faced significant closure and cutbacks in the wake of increased council austerity.

 

Nearly all London boroughs have cut funding to their youth projects and services, with some councils cutting funding by as much as 600% since 2014. Only two of London’s boroughs didn't cut their youth spending in 2017/18 compared to the previous year.

 

While youth centres still operate in some capacity in all of London's boroughs, the distance some children would have to travel can mean it is too dangerous for them to attend. “Young kids don’t want to walk through rival kids terrority to get there as that puts them at risk so they simply won’t go” says Dr Harding.

 

The city’s remaining youth centres are shadows of their former selves, Dr Harding went on to say. “The centres that do still exist now have a ping pong table and a pool table and that’s about it. What is needed is massive investment, to proactively bring people off the streets with a collection of youth workers there to engage with these people.”

 

The Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, has publicly criticised the cuts. “Prevention is the most effective tool we have, which is why it is extremely disappointing that the government has repeatedly slashed funding on support and activities for young Londoners over the last eight years.” he said as part of the announcement of a new £45m fund to help young people in London at risk of being caught up in crime.

London Youth Centre budgets slashed by

 

 

-88%

​

 

Source: Data obtained under FOI 

Image: Wikimedia Commons

Mapped: London's Youth Centres 

Above: London's youth centres are suffering as a result of local council cuts to funding. Some boroughs have cut spending by over 400% since 2010. Havering now only operates two youth centres for the entire borough. Data for this map came from information obtained under the Freedom of Information act.

"The police are irrelevant, if not that they are invisible and inconsequential completely.”

 

Photo by Unsplash

An Ineffective

Policing

Strategy.

The Metropolitan Police have also suffered significant cuts, especially to their Police Community Support Officer (PCSOs) programmes that are vital in engaging community members. Numbers of PSCOs in London has fallen 68% since 2010.

 

This has resulted in a radical change in the way policing and community engagement works in the city. “These PCSOs were the ones with their finger on the pulse of the community, they could identify the young people at risk of gang affiliation and work with them,” says Dr Harding “This is all lost.”

 

The Home Office, in their Serious Violence Strategy, highlighted the importance of early intervention and prevention and supporting communities and local partnerships.

 

Scotland Yard lead officer for gang violence, Commander Jim Stokely, writing in the Metropolitan Police Blog, said the Police is also committed to preventative work. “What we want is to do all we can to stop young people from joining a gang in the first place. Londoners can help us - we all have a part to play."

 

However policing is now focused on patrol rather than community interaction, with Police officers having to cover more ground in less time. Shaun Willshire, a former police officer, says the changes are putting increased pressure on officers, “I have never seen so much demand made of supervisors, I think that a police Sergeant or Inspector will now spend 30 of their 40 hour weeks in front of a computer.”

 

This reduction in youth engagement is changing the way the youth see authority as well, according to Dr Harding. “The boys I've spoken to tell me the police are now irrelevant, if not that they are invisible and inconsequential completely.”

Dr Simon Harding

An expert in criminology and youth gangs in London

Image: Middlesex University

"Of course what is doesn't show is that he now owns them, they have to go out and do the drug dealing, sit out on the street corners, and they are ones who are getting stabbed."

 

Photo by Jaclyn Moy on Unsplash

Photo by Jaclyn Moy on Unsplash

Drill.

A new sub-genre of rap music, Drill, has recently been targeted for promoting gang culture. The music is often written, produced and filmed by gangs themselves. Members will often appear in balaclavas and masks, using violent lyrics, alcohol and drugs and even displaying weapons.

 

Dr Harding argues Drill is used by gangs as a recruitment tool. “Drill is essentially a commercial promo for their gang, they are talking about real people, real violence and real drugs. This is very different from the general discussion of hip-hop and grime compared to Drill, which is more oral artistic representation of grim and present violent life on streets.”

 

A Drill music producer, known only as ‘Daniel’ told LBC that Drill isn't to blame and that it is only "kids expressing themselves through music."

 

Others, such as Nana Agyeman think that Drill is in part, a symptom, not the sole cause of gang culture. “The reason people target drill as a cause is because of the influence. You have a young person repeatedly hearing all these negative things, Drill music is basic in its content, it is shootings, stabbings the drug dealing and the confrontation, that can be damaging.”

 

It is not always the violence in Drill that is the problem, says Shaun Willshire, who works with the charity Growing Against Violence. He believes the glamour in the videos can have a worrying effect on some children. “99.9% of the kids in London are absolutely brilliant, they have no intention of carrying a weapon, but in a few there is a genuine belief in the myths that surround gangs, the glamour, the excitement, the money.”

 

In May 2018, the video sharing website YouTube removed a number of Drill videos at the request of Operation Domain, the Metropolitan police’s strategy targeting violent online content.

 

“A nigga got burst. Nigga want to take my life, I guarantee Ima take his first. Skirt-skirt in the three litre volvo, rollin round with the mac on burst."

​

67 - Hookahs

Drill often features hyper-violent lyrics, such as this sample, where the word burst refers to someone being shot. Skirt-skirt refers to the sound of sports car tires skidding on tarmac

“All the recruitment, all the bullying and surveillance, all the drug dealing, all the posturing and posing is online now as well.”

 

Photo by Tom Sodoge on Unsplash

The 

Digital

Gang.

But Drill music is only one way in which gangs are utilising new forms of digital content, with social media playing an increasing important part in gang culture.

 

Dr Harding points out that what once happened in the community, or as gangs say “on road”, now happens in the online social space as well. “All the recruitment, all the bullying and surveillance, all the drug dealing, all the posturing and posing is online as well.” This has the overarching effect of pulling people who would not normally be exposed to this culture into the orbit of the gang, an effect not seen in previous generations.

 

Academics have also noticed a distinct change in the way gangs communicate online “Language has undergone a step change in these kids, the level of articulated violence, the vocabulary and clear level of intent gives me in the impression the person really means it and it's going to happen.“ This, coupled with the instantaneous nature of social media, can lead to rapid flare-ups in violence.

Because we either tackle this issue now, or we don't. If we don't, it will get much worse, and it will calcify, solidify, and be with us forever.

 

Photo by Unsplash

The solution?

London's gang culture is a grand accumulation of all these factors. The most vulnerable are left feeling abstract, confused about their identity and removed from civil life, leading a small minority to turn to the gang as a source of belonging and income. Dr Harding describes gang culture as a “lost subterranean tier of young people, estranged from the things that anchor normal people to society.”

 

Any approach to solving this issue needs to be community driven, says Patrick Green. “It needs to be about preventative work in the first instance, then intervention, and finally enforcement. This is not an issue London can police its way out of, clamping down on communities to protect them could risk alienating them.” In chicago, part of the reason the anti-gang movement was so successful, was the groundswell of the community rallying to demand action against gang killings.

 

AccessUK is taking the idea of ‘community driven’ a step further by developing an anti-gang, neighborhood-watch style guardian system. Their idea is to train members of the community to act as positive role models and mediate conflict, so they can effectively engage with the community. They would act in part as a buffer zone between the police and the community.

 

Whatever approach is taken, the solution must focus on building self esteem, self confidence and stemming the identity crisis among London’s BME youth by teaching them there is always a place for them in society. There needs to be a focus on not only positive, but visible role models for them to aspire to and seek guidance from, to act as living proof that gang culture is not the only way forward.

"Preventative work in the first instance, then intervention, and finally enforcement."

References

​

Assets.publishing.service.gov.uk. (2018). [online] Available at: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/491802/horr88.pdf [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Benkinsella.org.uk. (2018). [online] Available at: http://www.benkinsella.org.uk/files/Ben-Kinsella-Trust-Impact-Report.pdf [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Cardiff.ac.uk. (2018). [online] Available at: https://www.cardiff.ac.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/1162414/National-Violence-Surveillance-Network-Report-2017.pdf [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Globaldrugsurvey.com. (2018). Global Drug Survey. [online] Available at: https://www.globaldrugsurvey.com/ [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Gov.scot. (2018). Recorded Crime in Scotland, 2016-17. [online] Available at: http://www.gov.scot/Publications/2017/09/3075/downloads [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

GOV.UK. (2018). Police recorded crime and outcomes open data tables. [online] Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/police-recorded-crime-open-data-tables [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

GOV.UK. (2018). Police workforce, England and Wales: 31 March 2017. [online] Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/police-workforce-england-and-wales-31-march-2017 [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

GOV.UK. (2018). Serious Violence Strategy. [online] Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/serious-violence-strategy [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

London City Hall. (2018). First projects benefiting from £45m Young Londoners Fund announced. [online] Available at: https://www.london.gov.uk/press-releases/mayoral/mayor-urges-government-to-act-on-knife-crime [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Mail Online. (2018). What is drill music and why is it linked to violent crime?. [online] Available at: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/wires/pa/article-5815791/What-drill-music-linked-violent-crime.html [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Mynewsdesk. (2018). Cmdr Jim Stokley talks about managing threat of gang violence. [online] Available at: http://news.met.police.uk/blog_posts/cmdr-jim-stokley-talks-about-managing-threat-of-gang-violence-69400 [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Ons.gov.uk. (2018). Crime in England and Wales - Office for National Statistics. [online] Available at: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/bulletins/crimeinenglandandwales/yearendingseptember2017 [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Ons.gov.uk. (2018). X02 Regional labour market: Estimates of unemployment by age - Office for National Statistics. [online] Available at: https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peoplenotinwork/unemployment/datasets/regionalunemploymentbyagex02 [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Publications.parliament.uk. (2018). House of Commons - Gangs and youth crime - Home Affairs. [online] Available at: https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201415/cmselect/cmhaff/199/19905.htm [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

​

Publications.parliament.uk. (2018). House of Commons - Gangs and youth crime - Home Affairs. [online] Available at: https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201415/cmselect/cmhaff/199/19905.htm [Accessed 14 Jun. 2018].

bottom of page